English Learners Q&A

What’s Ahead for the 5.3 Million English Learners in Our Schools?

By Ileana Najarro — December 19, 2024 6 min read
Photograph of a Hispanic elementary school girl writing at her desk in a classroom setting
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Montserrat Garibay arrived in the United States three decades ago with her mother and sister as an undocumented immigrant, and learned English at a public middle school in Austin, Texas. Later on, she worked as a bilingual pre-kindergarten teacher before becoming a labor organizer in Texas, first representing Austin public school employees and then serving as a top leader of the Texas AFL-CIO.

For the past four years, she’s been at the U.S. Department of Education, first as the senior adviser for labor relations to Education Secretary Miguel Cardona and, for the past two years, as deputy assistant secretary and director of the department’s office of English-language acquisition.

She’ll leave that position on Jan. 20 at the start of Donald Trump’s new administration, when it’s unclear exactly what federal policy toward English learners will look like.

In Garibay’s time leading the office of English language acquisition, or OELA, it has taken back the responsibility of managing the primary federal funding stream that supports supplemental services for English learners: the $890 million Title III grant program.

In an interview with Education Week, she touted the office’s work to develop resources designed to highlight best practices for school districts in welcoming newly arrived students, introduce Mexican consulates in the United States to resources and services that should be available to English learners in public schools, award grants to states to grow their pool of in-demand bilingual educators, and celebrate the nationwide growth of the seal of biliteracy—a distinction high school graduates, English learners and non-English learners alike, can earn for mastering English plus another language.

Some of OELA’s work in recent years has been internal: aimed at ensuring that other divisions of the U.S. Department of Education are considering the needs of the nation’s growing population of about 5.3 million English learners as they administer grants and develop policy.

She spoke with Education Week as her office on Dec. 19 released a series of four “playbooks” aimed at advancing another key OELA priority: growing dual-language immersion programs in which English learners and non-English learners learn academic content alongside each other in both English and another language. The playbooks highlight the work five states have undertaken to grow the number of dual-language immersion programs—considered a promising model for boosting English learners’ academic achievement.

Garibay spoke about her office’s work to champion this model, the progress she’s seen in recent years to improve services for English learners, and the work that remains with a new administration soon taking office.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Can you share more about the newest dual-language resources OELA has published?

Montserrat Garibay

We identified five states: New York, Utah, California, Texas, and North Carolina. We chose these five states because they have 200-plus dual-language programs. We visited elementary, middle schools, and high schools that had dual-language programs. We talked to different stakeholders and had roundtable conversations about, what were the key factors that these schools put in place in their communities to have these dual-language programs?

And one of the great things about this is that all of the schools that we visited—the 19 schools that we visited in total—were public schools. So we were able to see high, evidence-based, quality dual-language programs in action in our public schools, and we learned from them about their policies, their processes, the strategies, their practices, how they’re funding these dual-language programs.

Now we are able to release these four playbooks, with their focus on policy, foundational conditions, family and community engagement, and staffing. We’re highlighting the different aspects that each of these states are doing to promote these important programs.

We went to North Carolina. We went to the first Urdu dual language program, which started in 2018. It’s a partnership with a university, and we were able to see how students were learning Urdu and how that came about, how it was really a grassroots movement from parents and the community to bring this program to the kids.

In Utah, we saw how thoughtful they have been in terms of the professional development of their teachers, how now they’re moving to having their professional development in Spanish [for dual-language immersion teachers]. I think one of the things that we saw within each of the states was the multilingual and bilingual teachers, and each of these states are doing different things to make sure that they have the most qualified dual-language teachers doing the work.

What work remains to support English learners nationally?

One of the areas that we still need to focus on is students in special education who are English learners, who are as capable as anybody in learning their heritage language in dual-language programs. So much more information needs to, and support needs to, come from the department to ensure that the students are receiving the resources that they need.

See Also

Photo of teacher and blind student using braille slate.
E+

How has the department ensured English learners are not an afterthought in policy and spending? How can that continue under Trump?

One of the first things that I did when I came to OELA was have a national convening where we had 3,000 people.

We had the office for civil rights share specific cases where districts and states were not following the law, and we highlighted how they were able to fix that. As I’m reflecting and thinking of the work that we’ve done, I feel like, through these years with OELA, we have really been thoughtful and intentional in reminding educators, stakeholders, and parents of the obligation that states and districts have to our 5.3 million English learners.

See Also

High school teacher Tara Hobson talks with a student in the school cafeteria at San Francisco International High School in San Francisco on April 19, 2016. Some districts have gone to extraordinary lengths to accommodate migrant students, who often come to join relatives, sometimes escaping criminal gangs or extreme poverty. San Francisco International High School rewrote young-adult novels at a basic level to spark the newcomers' interest in reading.
High school teacher Tara Hobson talks with a student in the school cafeteria at San Francisco International High School in San Francisco on April 19, 2016. The quality of education for English learners, including migrant students in San Francisco, has evolved over the last years in part due to landmark civil rights Supreme Court decision.
Jeff Chiu/AP

We also know that if this set of students do well in our nation, our whole nation will be doing even better.

I feel that because the secretary has definitely raised the bar in terms of English learners and has showed the world and the United States that these students actually are the valedictorians from many high schools, that are graduating with honors because they actually know how to read, speak, and write in their native language, but also in English. And that is a superpower that will take them far.

But now, as the new administration comes, I think it’s going to be really important for parents, educators, and students to be unapologetic of the strength that they have to utilize all the different “dear colleague” letters, all the different information that we have provided so they can exercise their rights, so they can demand a good-quality education for them, for their children, and for their students.

What outgoing message do you have for multilingual educators, students, and families?

I came to the United States as an undocumented student.

For me it’s been very personal, because I’m able to be in this role because of the public education that I received, because I am bilingual. I am just a tiny example of what can be done, and to really embrace the beauty of the American dream. And to be able to serve at this level has been a great opportunity and a great responsibility.

I know that throughout these two years that I have been part of OELA, I have seen teachers, students, and parents who are hungry for a better education. What we’ve done these years under Secretary Cardona’s leadership will transform the lives of our students, so I’m very proud of that, and we’re definitely raising the bar.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Assessment Webinar
Measuring What Matters: How District Leaders Are Redefining Student Assessment
In this panel discussion, district leaders and systems experts will examine the gap between the outcomes we want and the systems in place.
Content provided by Otus
Early Childhood Webinar Selling Into Early Learning: New Survey Data and Strategies for Marketers
Selling into PreK? Get fresh EdWeek Research Center data and strategies to position your products and reach the right early learning buyers.
Artificial Intelligence Webinar AI and 'Techlash' Are on a Collision Course. How Should Schools Respond?
Learn what strategies and tactics schools can develop to encourage smart and responsible AI use, while also enforcing tech guardrails.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

English Learners How Tech Can Help or Harm Instruction for English Learners With Disabilities
Devices and AI-powered tools can lead to engagement or isolation, researchers and advocates say.
3 min read
Chromebooks, to be loaned to students in the Elk Grove Unified School District, await distribution at Monterey Trail High School in Elk Grove, Calif., on April 2, 2020.
Chromebooks fill a shelf at a high school in Elk Grove, Calif., on April 2, 2020. In a recent Education Week webinar on how to support English learners with disabilities, Sara Kangas, an associate professor at Lehigh University’s college of education and a participant in the discussion, suggested teachers consider whether the technology being used is hurting or helping peer-to-peer interactions among English learners with disabilities.
Rich Pedroncelli/AP
English Learners Strategies to Support English Learners: 3 Takeaways for School Districts
States and school systems are wrestling with how to help learners of English of all age levels.
3 min read
Student Elias Albert gets help from Nurit Foster, who is using artificial intelligence in her multilingual learners class at Hillside Middle School in Northville, Mich., on Jan. 13, 2025 . AI allows teachers in Northville to provide students with content for a class assignment and then adjust the levels for each student based on their English proficiency, officials said. Some districts are also using AI tools to help with translation for families.
Student Elias Albert gets help from Nurit Foster, who is using artificial intelligence in her multilingual learners class at Hillside Middle School in Northville, Mich., on Jan. 13, 2025. AI allows teachers in Northville to provide students with content for a class assignment and then adjust the levels for each student based on their English proficiency, officials said. Some districts are also using AI tools to help with translation for families.
Daniel Mears/The Detroit News via TNS
English Learners 4 Lessons From One State's Move Away From Formal Pre-K Language Testing
California is shifting from formal assessments to play-based screeners for its youngest learners.
5 min read
Citlali Márquez-Hamil dances during a Transitional Kindergarten class at First Street Elementary School in Los Angeles, on April 22, 2026.
Citlali Márquez-Hamil dances during a transitional kindergarten class at First Street Elementary School in Los Angeles, on April 22, 2026. During a recent Education Week webinar, experts discussed California's shift to play-based screeners, including how they work, the risk of student misidentification, and implementation oversight.
Ethan Swope/AP
English Learners Reports Teaching Multilingual Learners: Results of a National Survey
Based on an educator survey, this report examines views on staffing, instructional approaches, and training to teach multilingual learners.